20 July 2020, 19:45 · 23rd Knesset · vote no. 33101
חוק לתיקון ולהארכת תוקפן של תקנות שעת חירום (נגיף הקורונה החדש - דיונים בהשתתפות עצורים, אסירים וכלואים) (תיקון מס' 2), התש"ף-2020Law to amend and extend the validity of Emergency Regulations (new coronavirus - discussions with the participation of detainees, prisoners and confined persons) (Amendment No. 2), 2020 · AI translation · suggest a correction
אישור החוק
Law passed: 45 for, 25 against
70 of 120 voted — official Knesset result
What was put to the vote
«לקבל את הצעת החוק בקריאה שלישית»
Third reading: The final vote. A bill that passes its third reading becomes law. Glossary →
About the law and the debate
Official summary of the law (Knesset)
It was decided to amend the Law for the Amendment and Extension of the Validity of Emergency Regulations (New Coronavirus – Hearings with the Participation of Detainees, Prisoners and Inmates) and to establish that a detainee or prisoner in isolation shall participate in a hearing by technological means, and if there is a real concern that they have been infected, or have come into contact with a patient, officials in the Prison Service shall be authorized to determine that the hearing will be held with their participation by technological means. It was further decided to authorize the Minister of Justice and the Minister of Public Security to declare, under certain conditions and subject to subsequent approval by the Constitution Committee, that hearings will not be held in the presence of detainees or prisoners. It was also decided to establish parallel arrangements regarding the participation of inmates in hearings before military courts.
AI translation · suggest a correction
Hebrew original
הוחלט לתקן את החוק לתיקון ולהארכת תוקפן של תקנות שעת חירום (נגיף הקורונה החדש – דיונים בהשתתפות עצורים, אסירים וכלואים) ולקבוע כי עצור או אסיר הנמצאים בבידוד ישתתפו בדיון באמצעים טכנולוגיים ואם יש חשש ממשי שנדבקו, או באו במגע עם חולה, יוסמכו גורמים בשירות בתי הסוהר לקבוע כי הדיון יתקיים בהשתתפותם באמצעים טכנולוגיים. עוד הוחלט להסמיך את שר המשפטים והשר לביטחון פנים להכריז, בתנאים מסויימים ובאישור בדיעבד של ועדת החוקה, על אי-קיום דיונים בנוכחות עצורים או אסירים. כמו כן, הוחלט לקבוע הסדרים מקבילים לעניין השתתפות כלואים בדיונים בבתי הדין הצבאיים.
What was said in the plenum
Supporters saidAI summaryThere is a need to protect the health of detainees, prisoners and the public under the crowded incarceration conditions during the virus outbreak, and therefore the possibility of holding hearings via video conference should be expanded.Speakers who made this point: 1Opponents saidAI summaryThe law infringes on the fundamental rights of detainees and prisoners, including the right to a fair process, the right to consult with a lawyer, and the right to be physically present at a hearing determining their fate, since a Zoom hearing may be disrupted, disconnected, and unequal.Speakers who made this point: 513 members spoke · 16 reservations
Summarised by an AI model (Claude) from the plenum transcripts: the argument each side made most often, paraphrased, not quoted. Transcript of the sitting: 1 · write to the author
By party on the day of the vote
Coalition and opposition voted differently.
- for
- abstained
- against
Likudהליכודcoalition17 for · 0 against — majority for
- Zeev Elkinfor
- Keren Barakfor
- Nir Barkatfor
- May Golanfor
- Gila Gamlielfor
- Uzi Dayanfor
- Avi Dicterfor
- Tzachi Hanegbifor
- Desta Gadi Yevarkanfor
- Eli Cohenfor
- Ofir Katzfor
- Yariv Levinfor
- Fateen Mullafor
- Etty Hava Atiafor
- Tali Ploskovfor
- Shlomo Karhifor
- Yuval Steinitzfor
Joint Listהרשימה המשותפת חד"ש, רע"מ, תע"ל, בל"דopposition0 for · 14 against — majority against
- Samy Abu Shahadehagainst
- Saeed Alkharumiagainst
- Yousef Jabareenagainst
- Iman Khatib Yassinagainst
- Waleed Tahaagainst
- Ahmad Tibiagainst
- Heba Yazbakagainst
- Ofer Cassifagainst
- Sondos Salehagainst
- Osama Saadiagainst
- Mansour Abbasagainst
- Jaber Asaklaagainst
- Mtanes Shihadehagainst
- Aida Touma Slimanagainst
Blue and Whiteכחול לבןcoalition10 for · 0 against — majority for
Yesh Atid – Telemיש עתיד - תל"םopposition0 for · 9 against — majority against
- Boaz Toporovskyagainst
- Moshe Ya`alonagainst
- Meir Cohenagainst
- Yorai Lahav Hertzanuagainst
- Mickey Levyagainst
- Yoav Segalovitzagainst
- Orly Fromanagainst
- Andrey Kozhinovagainst
- Ofer Shelahagainst
Shasש"סcoalition7 for · 0 against — majority for
United Torah Judaismיהדות התורה והשבת אגודת ישראל - דגל התורהcoalition6 for · 0 against — majority for
Laborהעבודה הישראליתcoalition1 for · 1 against — no majority
- Merav Michaeliagainst
- Amir Peretzfor
Roll call (70)
Numbers and sources
- For
- 45
- Against
- 25
- Abstained
- 0
- Present, did not vote
- 0
Official result: 44 for, 24 against, 0 abstained — adopted. According to the source, 2 roll-call records were not counted in the official result (vote declared or corrected after the vote). Taking that into account, the roll call matches the official result.
Only members with a record are counted. No record does not mean the member was absent.