Government bill · 25th Knesset · published as law 25 January 2023

חוק להארכת תוקפן של תקנות שעת חירום (יהודה והשומרון – שיפוט בעבירות ועזרה משפטית), התשפ"ג-2023Law to extend the validity of Emergency Regulations (Judea and Samaria – Jurisdiction in Offenses and Legal Assistance), 2023 · AI translation · suggest a correction

Status: התקבלה בקריאה שלישית

Topics: Military and defense*, Courts and criminal law*, Emergency, war and COVID* · * from the Knesset's official law classification

Official summary of the law (Knesset)

The Law to Extend the Validity of the Emergency Regulations (Judea and Samaria – Adjudication of Offenses and Legal Assistance), 2023 was passed in second and third reading on 24 January 2023. The Law extended by five years, until 15 February 2028, the validity of the Emergency Regulations (Judea and Samaria – Adjudication of Offenses and Legal Assistance), 1967. The Regulations deal with the legal relations between Israel and the Judea and Samaria area, including the regulation of life and powers regarding Israelis residing there (for example: granting authority to courts in Israel to adjudicate, under Israeli law, matters concerning an Israeli who committed criminal offenses in the area; establishing policing powers for Israel Police officers to act regarding criminal offenses over which courts in Israel or military courts in the area have jurisdiction; expanding the powers of those granted authority in Israel in matters of taxation, execution, cooperative societies, associations, and more, to exercise their powers also in the area), and legal assistance between Israel and the Palestinian Authority.

AI translation · suggest a correction

Hebrew original

חוק להארכת תוקפן של תקנות שעת חירום (יהודה והשומרון – שיפוט בעבירות ועזרה משפטית), התשפ"ג-2023 התקבל בקריאה השנייה ובקריאה השלישית ביום ב' בשבט תשפ"ג (24 בינואר 2023). החוק האריך בחמש שנים, עד ה-15 בפברואר 2028, את תוקפן של תקנות שעת חירום (יהודה והשומרון – שיפוט בעבירות ועזרה משפטית), התשכ"ז-1967. התקנות עוסקות ביחסי הגומלין המשפטיים בין ישראל לבין אזור יהודה והשומרון, לרבות הסדרת החיים והסמכויות לגבי ישראלים המתגוררים בו (דוגמת: הקניית סמכות לבתי המשפט בישראל לדון, לפי הדין הישראלי, בעניינו של ישראלי שביצע עבירות פליליות באזור; קביעת סמכויות שיטור לשוטרי משטרת ישראל לפעול ביחס לעבירות פליליות שבתי משפט בישראל או בתי משפט צבאיים באזור מוסמכים לדון בהן; הרחבת סמכויותיהם של מי שהוקנו להם בישראל סמכויות בענייני מיסים, הוצאה לפועל, אגודות שיתופיות, עמותות ועוד, להפעיל את סמכויותיהם גם באזור), והעזרה המשפטית בין ישראל לרשות הפלסטינית.

Readings

What was said in the plenum

The bill seeks to extend by an additional five years (until February 2028) the validity of the emergency regulations governing the jurisdiction of Israeli courts over Israelis living in Judea and Samaria and the provision of legal assistance between Israel and the Palestinian Authority. The debate focused much less on the legal-bureaucratic content of the law itself and more on its political-moral question: who has been consistent in their position over time, whether this constitutes apartheid or annexation, and what approving the law says about the Zionist or binational character of the current government.

AI translation · suggest a correction

Hebrew original

הצעת החוק מבקשת להאריך בחמש שנים נוספות (עד פברואר 2028) את תוקפן של תקנות שעת החירום המסדירות את שיפוט בתי המשפט בישראל כלפי ישראלים הגרים ביהודה ושומרון ואת מתן העזרה המשפטית בין ישראל לרשות הפלסטינית. הדיון התמקד הרבה פחות בתוכן המשפטי-ביורוקרטי של החוק עצמו ויותר בשאלה הפוליטית-מוסרית שלו: מי עקבי בעמדתו לאורך זמן, האם יש כאן אפרטהייד או סיפוח, ומה אומר אישור החוק על אופייה הציוני או הדו-לאומי של הממשלה הנוכחית.

Arguments for

  • The law is essential in order to prevent a legal void and to preserve rights and legal order for Israeli citizens residing in Judea and Samaria.
    Yinon Azoulay (Shas), Yariv Levin (Likud), Gideon Sa'ar (National Unity)
  • This is a technical-principled law that should be voted on based on substantive and national considerations rather than narrow coalition considerations, and therefore it should be consistently supported whether one is in the coalition or in the opposition.
    Gideon Sa'ar (National Unity), Zeev Elkin (National Unity)
  • Extending the Regulations is also required for the proper functioning of law enforcement and policing in Judea and Samaria.
    Gideon Sa'ar (National Unity)
  • Unlike the previous government, which relied on elements that opposed settlement and was unwilling to extend the regulations, the current government is committed to the Zionist vision and to strengthening settlement, and is passing the law easily and by a clear majority.
    Yariv Levin (Likud), Yoav Kisch (Likud)

Arguments against

  • The Regulations create two separate legal systems for Israelis and Palestinians in the same territory, which constitutes a regime of apartheid and de facto annexation that should be ended rather than extended.
    Yasir Hujeirat (Ra'am), Ahmad Tibi (Hadash–Ta'al), Aida Touma Sliman (Hadash–Ta'al), Ofer Cassif (Hadash–Ta'al)
  • The current government is an annexation government with no vision for separation from the Palestinians or for a political solution, and therefore it should not be given tools (such as the Regulations) that would allow it to create facts on the ground and prevent a future solution.
    Merav Michaeli (Labor), Gilad Kariv (Labor)
  • Those who currently vote in favor of the law are hypocrites, since the same coalition members voted against extending the identical Regulations when they were in the opposition, out of narrow political considerations rather than principled ones, turning the residents of Judea and Samaria into a political plaything.
    Yulia Malinovsky (Yisrael Beytenu), Matan Kahana (National Unity), Yifat Shasha Biton (National Unity), Zeev Elkin (National Unity), Mickey Levy (Yesh Atid)
  • The Regulations should be extended for a period much longer than five years (ten years or even more), rather than continuing this temporary and limited mechanism every five years.
    Yulia Malinovsky (Yisrael Beytenu), Matan Kahana (National Unity), Zeev Elkin (National Unity)
  • The division of authority and responsibility over Judea and Samaria among various ministers in the current government harms proper administration and the security of soldiers and the state.
Who spoke (25)
MemberFactionReadingsSpeechesIn the final vote
Yinon AzoulayShas coalitionThird reading2for
Mansour AbbasRa'am oppositionThird reading1against
Waleed AlhwashlaRa'am oppositionThird reading1no record
Iman Khatib YassinRa'am oppositionThird reading1against
Yasir HujeiratRa'am oppositionThird reading1against
Sharon NirYisrael Beytenu oppositionFirst reading, Third reading2for
Yulia MalinovskyYisrael Beytenu oppositionThird reading3for
Matan KahanaNational Unity oppositionThird reading1no record
Merav MichaeliLabor oppositionThird reading1against
Naama LazimiLabor oppositionThird reading1against
Gilad KarivLabor oppositionFirst reading, Third reading2against
Ahmad TibiHadash–Ta'al oppositionThird reading1against
Aida Touma SlimanHadash–Ta'al oppositionFirst reading, Third reading2against
Ofer CassifHadash–Ta'al oppositionFirst reading, Third reading2against
Yariv LevinLikud coalitionFirst reading1for
Meirav CohenYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading1no record
Gideon Sa'arNational Unity oppositionFirst reading1no record
Yifat Shasha BitonNational Unity oppositionFirst reading1no record
Moshe TurpazYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading2no record
Naor ShiriYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading2no record
Yorai Lahav HertzanuYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading1no record
Simon DavidsonYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading1no record
Zeev ElkinNational Unity oppositionFirst reading1no record
Mickey LevyYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading1no record
Yoav KischLikud coalitionFirst reading1for

Summarised by an AI model (Claude) from the plenum transcripts: the debate on the bill at every reading it was voted on. The arguments are paraphrases, not quotations, and the members listed under each are the model's reading of who made it: check the transcript before quoting anyone. This is not an assessment of which side is right. The list of who spoke comes from the transcript, without a model. Transcripts of the sittings: 1, 2 · write to the author

Reservations to the second reading

23 reservations were filed: proposed changes to the text the committee brought to the second and third reading.

The reservations were mainly intended to change the duration of the extension of the Regulations' validity (ranging from moving it up to 2024 to extending it until 2038), to condition the extension on various political and security conditions such as reporting to the Knesset, preserving residents' rights and military authority, and also to change the name of the law and its wording.

AI translation · suggest a correction

Hebrew original

ההסתייגויות נועדו בעיקרן לשנות את משך הארכת תוקף התקנות (בין הקדמתו לשנת 2024 להארכתו עד 2038), להתנות את ההארכה בתנאים מדיניים וביטחוניים שונים כגון דיווח לכנסת, שמירה על זכויות תושבים וסמכות הצבא, וכן לשנות את שם החוק ואת ניסוחו.

By faction

  • Yesh Atid opposition · 15 reservations · 22 members
  • Yisrael Beytenu opposition · 4 reservations · 6 members
  • National Unity opposition · 2 reservations · 3 members
  • Ra'am opposition · 2 reservations · 5 members
  • Labor opposition · 1 reservation · 3 members

A joint reservation counts for every faction whose members filed it. 4 proposers were not matched to a member: listed under the groups, not counted by faction.

Who proposed what
  • ישראל ביתנו · 4
    The Yisrael Beiteinu group proposes extending the validity of the Regulations until 2033 or 2038 instead of 2028, and also changing the wording relating to the validity of the Regulations and the designation "emergency regulations."
    Sections: לסעיף 1
  • רם בן ברק · 4
    Member of Knesset Ram Ben Barak proposes conditioning the extension of the Regulations on preserving exclusive authority in the hands of the GOC Central Command, on maintaining the status quo, on holding a referendum, and on preventing harm to the judicial system.
    Sections: לסעיף 1
  • אלעזר שטרן · 4
    Member of Knesset Elazar Stern proposes shortening the validity of the Regulations until 2024 and conditioning their extension on non-intervention by non-military bodies, on preserving residents' rights, and on holding an annual discussion in the Knesset.
    Sections: לסעיף 1
  • מאיר כהן · 4
    Member of Knesset Meir Cohen proposes conditioning the extension of the regulations on the Minister of Defense appointing the head of the Civil Administration, on the Chief Military Rabbi being subordinate to the Chief of the General Staff, on annual reporting to the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, and on the non-appointment of legal advisors by the Director General.
    Sections: לסעיף 1
  • רע״ם · 2
    The Ra'am group proposes changing the name of the law so that it would be called "Dictatorship Regulations," and the reference to "Judea and Samaria" would be replaced with "the Palestinian territories."
    Sections: לשם החוק
  • זאב אלקין · 2
    MK Ze'ev Elkin, as part of a joint proposal, proposes extending the validity of the Regulations to various alternative dates between 2029 and 2034.
    Sections: לסעיף 1
  • גדעון סער · 2
    Member of Knesset Gideon Sa'ar, as part of a joint proposal, proposes extending the validity of the Regulations to a range of alternative dates between 2029 and 2034.
    Sections: לסעיף 1
  • מתן כהנא · 2
    MK Matan Kahana, as part of a joint proposal, proposes extending the validity of the Regulations to various alternative dates between 2029 and 2034.
    Sections: לסעיף 1
  • שרן השכל · 2
    MK Sharren Haskel, as part of a joint proposal, proposes extending the validity of the Regulations to various alternative dates between 2029 and 2034, as well as to 2033.
    Sections: לסעיף 1
  • אורנה ברביבאי · 2
    MK Orna Barbivai proposes conditioning the extension of the Regulations on the consent of the Minister of Defense and on the government reporting to the Knesset every two years on advancing an alternative legislative solution.
    Sections: לסעיף 1
  • יש עתיד · 1
    The Yesh Atid group proposes changing the name of the Law and adding a section requiring the government to report to the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee every two years on the implementation of the Law and on changes in the manner of its execution.
    Sections: לאחרי סעיף 1
  • העבודה · 1
    The Labor group proposes stipulating that the commencement of the Law be conditional on the end of the term of the additional minister in the Ministry of Defense, on the start of the term of the 26th Knesset, or on a distant future date.
    Sections: לאחרי סעיף 1

Asked to speak: Moshe Solomon (Religious Zionism), Boaz Bismuth (Likud), Gadi Eisenkot (National Unity), Ayman Odeh (Hadash–Ta'al), Ahmad Tibi (Hadash–Ta'al), Aida Touma Sliman (Hadash–Ta'al), Ofer Cassif (Hadash–Ta'al), Youssef Atauna (Hadash–Ta'al), Benjamin Gantz (National Unity), Pnina Tameno (National Unity), Yifat Shasha Biton (National Unity), Chili Tropper (National Unity), Michael Mordechai Biton (National Unity), Orit Farkash Hacohen (National Unity), Alon Schuster (National Unity)

Proposers and reservation numbers are extracted automatically from the committee version, and the count is checked against the numbers printed in it. The descriptions are summarised by an AI model. Committee version for the second and third reading (PDF) · write to the author

Reservations, sections and other votes (4)

In order. Votes on reservations and individual sections are shown separately from the vote on the bill as a whole.

Source: bill page in the Knesset legislation database ↗