Government bill · 20th Knesset · published as law 11 August 2016

חוק תקציב המדינה לשנים 2017 ו-2018 (הוראות מיוחדות) (הוראת שעה), התשע"ו-2016State Budget Law for 2017 and 2018 (Special Provisions) (temporary provision), 2016 · AI translation · suggest a correction

Status: התקבלה בקריאה שלישית

Topics: State budget* · * from the Knesset's official law classification

Official summary of the law (Knesset)

The State Budget Law for 2017 and 2018 (Special Provisions) (Temporary Provision), 2016 (hereinafter - the Law), was passed in second and third reading on 2 August 2016. The law establishes supplementary arrangements to Basic Law: The State Budget for 2017 and 2018 (Special Provisions) (Temporary Provision), regarding the manner of actual management of the biennial budget, including specific adaptations of provisions in various laws relating to a regular annual budget law, to a situation of a biennial budget law. Detailed and special supplementary provisions were also established regarding the "convergence" mechanism, such that the report on the existence of differentials that the Government will submit to the Knesset, which is supposed to include, among other things, the expected amount of government expenditure for 2018, will not take into account amounts included in legislation that has not yet been completed or in government decisions that have not yet been approved. The balancing plan will be submitted to the Knesset no later than 1 November 2017, and if part of the balancing actions have been carried out and a differential still remains, an across-the-board cut of 1% of the amount of government expenditure will be made; however, the distribution of the reduction or amounts between the plans in the budget items that the Government decided to reduce will be brought for the prior approval of the Finance Committee, and if such approval is not given, the amounts will be reduced in all the plans under that budget item in equal proportion. If, after the across-the-board cut, a differential still remains, the Minister of Finance will be required to take actions within his authority under law in order to cover the resulting differential.

AI translation · suggest a correction

Hebrew original

חוק תקציב המדינה לשנים 2017 ו-2018 (הוראות מיוחדות) (הוראת שעה), התשע"ו-2016 (להלן – החוק), התקבל בקריאה השנייה והשלישית ביום כ''ז בתמוז התשע''ו (2.8.2016). החוק קובע הסדרים משלימים לחוק יסוד: תקציב המדינה לשנים 2017 ו-2018 (הוראות מיוחדות) (הוראת שעה), לגבי אופן הניהול בפועל של התקציב הדו-שנתי ובכלל זה קובע התאמות פרטניות של הוראות בחוקים שונים המתייחסות לחוק תקציב שנתי רגיל, למצב של חוק תקציב דו-שנתי. כן, נקבעו הוראות משלימות מפורטות ומיוחדות לעניין מנגנון "ההתכנסות" כך שהדוח לעניין קיום ההפרשים שתגיש הממשלה לכנסת שאמור לכלול בין היתר את סכום ההוצאה הממשלתית הצפויה לשנת 2018 לא יביא בחשבון סכומים המובאים בחקיקה שטרם הושלמה או בהחלטות ממשלה שטרם אושרו. התכנית המאזנת תוגש לכנסת לא יאוחר מיום 1.11.17 ואם בוצעו חלק מפעולות האיזון ונותר עדיין הפרש יעשה קיצוץ רוחבי של 1% מסכום ההוצאה הממשלתית, אולם חלוקת ההפחתה או הסכומים בין התכניות בסעיפי התקציב שבהם החליטה הממשלה להפחתת תובא לאישורה המוקדם של ועדת הכספים ואם לא ניתן אישור כאמור יופחתו הסכומים בכלל התכניות שבאותו סעיף תקציב ביחס שווה. אם לאחר הקיצוץ הרוחבי יוותר הפרש – יחוייב שר האוצר לבצע פעולות בתחום סמכותו לפי דין לשם כיסוי ההפרש שנוצר.

Readings

What was said in the plenum

The bills established a temporary provision under which the state budget for 2017 and 2018 would be a full two-year budget, while also establishing oversight and adjustment mechanisms (such as a reserve, across-the-board cuts, and a reporting obligation to the Finance Committee) ahead of the start of 2018. The debate focused mainly on the question of whether a two-year budget is a sound economic tool or a political move intended to ensure the survival of the government, and of the Netanyahu government in particular, alongside many related discussions on social, sectoral, and other issues.

AI translation · suggest a correction

Hebrew original

הצעות החוק קבעו הוראת שעה לפיה תקציב המדינה לשנים 2017 ו-2018 יהיה תקציב דו-שנתי מלא, ובמקביל נקבעו מנגנוני בקרה והתאמה (כגון רזרבה, קיצוץ רוחבי וחיוב בדיווח לוועדת הכספים) לקראת תחילת 2018. הדיון נסב בעיקרו על השאלה אם תקציב דו-שנתי הוא כלי כלכלי תקין או מהלך פוליטי שנועד להבטיח את שרידות הממשלה וממשלת נתניהו באופן מיוחד, לצד דיונים נלווים רבים בנושאים חברתיים, מגזריים ואחרים.

Arguments for

  • A two-year budget provides governmental and political stability to the government and prevents harm to programs due to the fall of the government or elections in the middle of the budget period.
    Yitzhak Cohen (Shas), Akram Hasson (Kulanu), Nurit Koren (Likud), Moshe Gafni (United Torah Judaism)
  • Control mechanisms, reserves and adjustment provisions were established in the law (such as a reserve of 3.5 billion shekels, an across-the-board cut of 1% subject to Finance Committee approval, and a government reporting obligation to the Knesset toward the end of 2017) that ensure the Knesset will continue to exercise oversight and that budgetary gaps will be corrected before they worsen.
    Yitzhak Cohen (Shas), Moshe Gafni (United Torah Judaism)
  • A two-year budget enables long-term planning and operational stability for government ministries and economic bodies, and successfully avoids budget freezes such as occurred when the budget was delayed and work proceeded on an automatic-pilot basis.
    Yitzhak Cohen (Shas), Nurit Koren (Likud)
  • The current Finance Minister is implementing significant social policy (expanding the medicine basket, a savings plan for every child, the Buyer's Price program, assistance for the elderly, and more), so his intentions should not be impugned merely because he was forced to accept the two-year budget due to coalition agreements.
    Merav Ben Ari (Kulanu), Akram Hasson (Kulanu)
  • The decision on a two-year budget was made as part of binding coalition agreements, and since the coalition expressed its wish for this, the decision should be accepted as it is, since in the end there is a majority in the Knesset that decides.
    Akram Hasson (Kulanu), Moshe Gafni (United Torah Judaism)

Arguments against

Who spoke (52)
MemberFactionReadingsSpeechesIn the final vote
Yitzhak CohenShas coalitionFirst reading4for
Ilan GilonMeretz oppositionFirst reading, Third reading5against
Tamar ZandbergMeretz oppositionFirst reading, Third reading4against
Ahmad TibiJoint List oppositionFirst reading, Third reading10against
Basel GhattasJoint List oppositionFirst reading, Third reading8against
Yaakov PerryYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading, Third reading2against
Erel MargalitZionist Union oppositionFirst reading, Third reading4against
Abd Al Hakeem Haj YahyaJoint List oppositionFirst reading, Third reading3against
Zehava GalonMeretz oppositionFirst reading1against
Yehiel Hilik BarZionist Union oppositionFirst reading4against
Ayelet Nahmias-VerbinZionist Union oppositionFirst reading, Third reading7against
Ofer ShelahYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading3against
Karine ElharrarYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading1against
Dov KheninJoint List oppositionFirst reading2against
Mickey LevyYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading, Third reading6against
Merav Ben AriKulanu coalitionFirst reading4for
Michal RozinMeretz oppositionFirst reading5against
Nachman ShaiZionist Union oppositionFirst reading, Third reading8against
Meir CohenYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading, Third reading5against
Aliza LavieYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading, Third reading9against
Omer BarlevZionist Union oppositionFirst reading, Third reading5against
Talab Abu ArarJoint List oppositionFirst reading2no record
Zouheir BahloulZionist Union oppositionFirst reading4no record
Haim JelinYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading, Third reading4against
Yousef JabareenJoint List oppositionFirst reading, Third reading4against
Osama SaadiJoint List oppositionFirst reading4against
Esawi FrejMeretz oppositionFirst reading, Third reading10no record
Jamal ZahalkaJoint List oppositionFirst reading, Third reading6no record
Yoseph YonahZionist Union oppositionFirst reading6against
Eytan BroshiZionist Union oppositionFirst reading, Third reading5against
Ksenia SvetlovaZionist Union oppositionFirst reading3no record
Yair LapidYesh Atid oppositionFirst reading3no record
Abdullah Abu MaarufJoint List oppositionFirst reading, Third reading4against
Michal BiranZionist Union oppositionFirst reading, Third reading5against
Yoel HassonZionist Union oppositionFirst reading4against
Masud GanaimJoint List oppositionFirst reading2against
Aida Touma SlimanJoint List oppositionFirst reading, Third reading4against
Menachem Eliezer MosesUnited Torah Judaism coalitionFirst reading1for
Orly Levi-AbekasisYisrael Beytenu coalitionFirst reading, Third reading6against
Akram HassonKulanu coalitionFirst reading1for
Yael Cohen ParanZionist Union oppositionFirst reading1against
Nurit KorenLikud coalitionFirst reading2for
Revital SwidZionist Union oppositionFirst reading3against
Itzik ShmuliZionist Union oppositionFirst reading4against
Merav MichaeliZionist Union oppositionFirst reading1against
Moshe GafniUnited Torah Judaism coalitionThird reading36for
Elazar SternYesh Atid oppositionThird reading1against
Manuel TrajtenbergZionist Union oppositionThird reading3against
Stav ShaffirZionist Union oppositionThird reading2against
Ayman OdehJoint List oppositionThird reading2against
Yael GermanYesh Atid oppositionThird reading1against
Isaac HerzogZionist Union oppositionThird reading1against

Summarised by an AI model (Claude) from the plenum transcripts: the debate on the bill at every reading it was voted on. The arguments are paraphrases, not quotations, and the members listed under each are the model's reading of who made it: check the transcript before quoting anyone. This is not an assessment of which side is right. The list of who spoke comes from the transcript, without a model. Transcripts of the sittings: 1, 2 · write to the author

Reservations to the second reading

51 reservations were filed: proposed changes to the text the committee brought to the second and third reading.

The reservations were intended to turn the state budget from a two-year budget (2017-2018) into a one-year budget for 2017 alone, to increase the oversight and approval by the Finance Committee and the Knesset over budgetary actions and budget changes, and to limit the use of surplus amounts to the education, welfare, and health budgets, in addition to changing the law's name and adding a reporting requirement to the Finance Committee.

AI translation · suggest a correction

Hebrew original

ההסתייגויות נועדו להפוך את תקציב המדינה מתקציב דו-שנתי (2017-2018) לתקציב חד-שנתי לשנת 2017 בלבד, להגביר את הפיקוח והאישור של ועדת הכספים והכנסת על פעולות תקציביות ושינויי תקציב, ולהגביל את השימוש בסכומים עודפים לתקציבי החינוך, הרווחה והבריאות, בנוסף לשינוי שם החוק ותוספת דיווח לוועדת הכספים.

By faction

  • Zionist Union opposition · 51 reservations · 24 members
  • Joint List opposition · 51 reservations · 13 members
  • Yesh Atid opposition · 51 reservations · 11 members
  • Yisrael Beytenu coalition · 51 reservations · 1 member
  • Meretz opposition · 51 reservations · 5 members

A joint reservation counts for every faction whose members filed it.

Who proposed what

Proposers and reservation numbers are extracted automatically from the committee version, and the count is checked against the numbers printed in it. The descriptions are summarised by an AI model. Committee version for the second and third reading (PDF) · write to the author

Reservations, sections and other votes (1)

In order. Votes on reservations and individual sections are shown separately from the vote on the bill as a whole.

Source: bill page in the Knesset legislation database ↗