4 March 2025, 05:30 · 25th Knesset · vote no. 43232
הצעת חוק נציב תלונות הציבור על שופטים (תיקון מס' 6), התשפ"ה–2025Bill on Ombudsman for Complaints against Judges (Amendment No. 6), 2025 · AI translation · suggest a correction
Law passed: 56 for, 48 against
104 of 120 voted — counted from roll-call records (no official result is published)
What was put to the vote
«לקבל את הצעת החוק בקריאה שלישית»
Third reading: The final vote. A bill that passes its third reading becomes law. Glossary →
About the law and the debate
Official summary of the law (Knesset)
It was determined that the election of the Commissioner for Public Complaints against Judges will be carried out by a committee of seven members, consisting of: the Minister of Justice, the Minister of Labor, a Knesset member chosen by the Knesset or by one of its committees, a retired judge chosen by the justices of the Supreme Court, a retired judge chosen by the presidents of the district courts, a retired rabbinical judge chosen by the two Chief Rabbis of Israel, and the National Public Defender. Each committee member may propose up to two candidates for the position, and the decision to appoint a commissioner will be made by a majority of the committee's serving members, meaning, as a rule, a majority of four members. The said committee is also authorized to remove the commissioner from office or suspend him, by a majority of five of its members. The proposed arrangement replaces the previous arrangement whereby the commissioner was elected by the Judicial Selection Committee, based on a joint proposal by the Minister of Justice and the President of the Supreme Court.
AI translation · suggest a correction
Hebrew original
נקבע כי בחירת נציב תלונות הציבור על השופטים תיעשה על ידי ועדה של שבעה חברים, שאלו חבריה: שר המשפטים, שר העבודה, חבר כנסת שתבחר הכנסת או ועדה מוועדותיה, שופט בדימוס שיבחרו שופטי בית המשפט העליון, שופט בדימוס שיבחרו הנשיאים של בתי המשפט המחוזיים, דיין בדימוס שיבחרו שני הרבנים הראשיים לישראל והסניגור הציבורי הארצי. כל אחד מחברי הוועדה יכול להציע עד שני מועמדים לתפקיד, וההחלטה על מינוי נציב תתקבל על דעת רוב החברים המכהנים בוועדה, כלומר, ככלל, ברוב של ארבעה חברים. הוועדה האמורה מוסמכת גם להעביר את הנציב מכהונתו או להשעותו, ברוב של חמישה מחבריה. ההסדר המוצע מחליף את ההסדר הקודם לפיו הנציב נבחר בידי הוועדה לבחירת שופטים, על פי הצעת שר המשפטים ונשיא בית המשפט העליון כאחד.
What was said in the plenum
Supporters saidAI summaryThe reason there is no commissioner is that the president (or deputy) and the Minister of Justice fail to reach agreement, leaving those entitled to file complaints hostage to a political-institutional dispute; the bill abolishes the veto right and allows appointment without dependence on such agreement.Speakers who made this point: 2Opponents saidAI summaryThe law creates a clear political majority on the selection committee (ministers and a Knesset representative from the coalition) compared with a minority of professionals from the judiciary, thereby allowing the coalition to effectively control who will examine complaints against judges and to exert political pressure on them.Speakers who made this point: 435 members spoke · 45 reservations
Summarised by an AI model (Claude) from the plenum transcripts: the argument each side made most often, paraphrased, not quoted. Transcripts of the sittings: 1, 2, 3 · write to the author
By party on the day of the vote
Coalition and opposition voted differently.
- for
- abstained
- against
Likudהליכודcoalition29 for · 0 against — majority for
- Yuli Yoel Edelsteinfor
- Amir Ohanafor
- Dan Illouzfor
- Avichay Avraham Buaronfor
- David Bitanfor
- Boaz Bismuthfor
- Sasson Sassi Guettafor
- Tally Gotlivfor
- May Golanfor
- Gila Gamlielfor
- Avi Dicterfor
- Galit Distel Atbaryanfor
- Eli Dallalfor
- Shalom Daninofor
- Amit Halevifor
- Nissim Vaturifor
- Ofir Katzfor
- Israel Katzfor
- Yariv Levinfor
- Hanoch Dov Milwidskyfor
- Tsega Melakufor
- Moshe Saadafor
- Afef Abedfor
- Etty Hava Atiafor
- Moshe Passalfor
- Shlomo Karhifor
- Eliyahu Revivofor
- Kathrin Shitritfor
- Osher Shkalimfor
Yesh Atidיש עתידopposition0 for · 22 against — majority against
- Karine Elharraragainst
- Debbie Bitonagainst
- Vladimir Beliakagainst
- Merav Ben Ariagainst
- Ram Ben Barakagainst
- Boaz Toporovskyagainst
- Moshe Turpazagainst
- Meir Cohenagainst
- Meirav Cohenagainst
- Ron Katzagainst
- Yorai Lahav Hertzanuagainst
- Yaron Leviagainst
- Mickey Levyagainst
- Yair Lapidagainst
- Tatiana Mazarskyagainst
- Shelly Tal Meronagainst
- Yoav Segalovitzagainst
- Yasmin Fridmanagainst
- Matti Sarfatti Harcaviagainst
- Elazar Sternagainst
- Naor Shiriagainst
- Michal Shir Segmanagainst
Shasהתאחדות הספרדים שומרי תורה תנועתו של מרן הרב עובדיה יוסף זצ"לcoalition10 for · 0 against — majority for
National Unityהמחנה הממלכתיopposition0 for · 8 against — majority against
- Gadi Eisenkotagainst
- Michael Mordechai Bitonagainst
- Benjamin Gantzagainst
- Chili Tropperagainst
- Matan Kahanaagainst
- Orit Farkash Hacohenagainst
- Alon Schusteragainst
- Pnina Tamenoagainst
Otzma Yehuditעוצמה יהודית בראשות איתמר בן גבירopposition6 for · 0 against — majority for
Religious Zionismהציונות הדתית בראשות בצלאל סמוטריץ'coalition5 for · 0 against — majority for
United Torah Judaismיהדות התורהcoalition5 for · 0 against — majority for
Yisrael Beytenuישראל ביתנוopposition0 for · 5 against — majority against
- Avigdor Libermanagainst
- Yulia Malinovskyagainst
- Sharon Niragainst
- Hamad Amaragainst
- Oded Foreragainst
Laborהעבודהopposition0 for · 4 against — majority against
- Naama Lazimiagainst
- Merav Michaeliagainst
- Gilad Karivagainst
- Efrat Rayten Maromagainst
Hadash–Ta'alחד"ש-תע"לopposition0 for · 4 against — majority against
- Ahmad Tibiagainst
- Ofer Cassifagainst
- Ayman Odehagainst
- Aida Touma Slimanagainst
Ra'amרע"םopposition0 for · 4 against — majority against
- Waleed Alhwashlaagainst
- Yasir Hujeiratagainst
- Iman Khatib Yassinagainst
- Waleed Tahaagainst
Roll call (104)
Numbers and sources
- For
- 56
- Against
- 48
- Abstained
- 0
- Present, did not vote
- 0
Only members with a record are counted. No record does not mean the member was absent. Official results for votes after July 2021 are not published in the open data.