28 March 2023, 12:45 · 25th Knesset · vote no. 38593
הצעת חוק זכויות החולה (תיקון מס' 13) (הסדרים לעניין מזון בבית חולים בחג הפסח), התשפ"ג–2023 (פ/397/25) (פ/398/25) (פ/1793/25) (פ/1888/25)Bill Patient's Rights Law (Amendment No. 13) (Arrangements Regarding Food in Hospitals on Passover), 2023 (P/397/25) (P/398/25) (P/1793/25) (P/1888/25) · AI translation · suggest a correction
Law passed: 48 for, 43 against
91 of 120 voted — counted from roll-call records (no official result is published)
What was put to the vote
«לקבל את הצעת החוק בקריאה שלישית»
Third reading: The final vote. A bill that passes its third reading becomes law. Glossary →
About the law and the debate
Official summary of the law (Knesset)
The Law authorizes hospital directors to establish provisions regarding the prohibition or restriction of bringing leavened products (chametz) into the hospital building, in whole or in part, as required for maintaining kosher dietary observance during the Passover holiday for hospitalized patients. The provisions shall be established after the director has considered other alternatives and taking into account patients' rights and needs. The director may take into account, among other things, the needs of patients' companions and staff. In addition, the Law establishes that the provisions shall be published permanently on the hospital's website, and if there is no such website – on the Ministry of Health's website, and signs regarding the provisions shall be posted in the hospital. The hospital director shall be authorized to appoint an employee to inform about the provisions. The Law clarifies that the provisions of this arrangement do not derogate from the provisions of any law relating to food kashrut.
AI translation · suggest a correction
Hebrew original
החוק מסמיך את מנהלי בתי החולים לקבוע הוראות בדבר איסור או הגבלה של הכנסת חמץ למבנה בית החולים, כולו או חלקו, הנדרשות לשם שמירת כשרות בחג הפסח עבור המאושפזים. קביעת ההוראות תעשה לאחר שהמנהל שקל חלופות אחרות ובהתחשב בזכויות המטופלים ובצורכיהם. המנהל רשאי להתחשב בין היתר בצורכי המלווים של המטופלים והעובדים. בנוסף, החוק קובע כי ההוראות יפורסמו באופן קבוע באתר האינטרנט של בית החולים ואם אין אתר כזה – באתר משרד הבריאות, ובבית החולים יוצבו שלטים בדבר ההוראות. מנהל בית החולים יהיה רשאי להסמיך עובד לשם יידוע על ההוראות. בחוק הובהר כי הוראות הסדר זה אינן גורעות מהוראות כל דין הנוגע לכשרות המזון.
What was said in the plenum
Supporters saidAI summaryThe Passover holiday and the prohibition on eating chametz are a central value agreed upon by most of the Jewish people, and preserving the Jewish character of the State of Israel and of the public space justifies this legislation, without harming non-Jewish hospitals.Speakers who made this point: 4Opponents saidAI summaryThe law harms fundamental rights – human dignity, personal autonomy and freedom from religion – of patients and visitors, and could in practice lead to searching through belongings and harm to helpless patients, as has already happened in the past as a result of similar provisions.Speakers who made this point: 1037 members spoke · 118 reservations
Summarised by an AI model (Claude) from the plenum transcripts: the argument each side made most often, paraphrased, not quoted. Transcripts of the sittings: 1, 2, 3 · write to the author
By party on the day of the vote
Coalition and opposition voted differently.
- for
- abstained
- against
Likudהליכודcoalition20 for · 1 against — majority for
- Yuli Yoel Edelsteinfor
- Amir Ohanafor
- Dan Illouzfor
- Boaz Bismuthfor
- Sasson Sassi Guettafor
- Tally Gotlivfor
- Eli Dallalfor
- Shalom Daninofor
- Amit Halevifor
- Nissim Vaturifor
- Ofir Katzfor
- Israel Katzfor
- Hanoch Dov Milwidskyfor
- Tsega Melakufor
- Moshe Saadaagainst
- Etty Hava Atiafor
- Moshe Passalfor
- Ariel Kallnerfor
- Eliyahu Revivofor
- Kathrin Shitritfor
- Osher Shkalimfor
Yesh Atidיש עתידopposition1 for · 20 against — majority against
- Karine Elharraragainst
- Debbie Bitonagainst
- Vladimir Beliakagainst
- Merav Ben Ariagainst
- Ram Ben Barakagainst
- Simon Davidsonagainst
- Moshe Turpazagainst
- Meirav Cohenagainst
- Ron Katzagainst
- Yorai Lahav Hertzanufor
- Mickey Levyagainst
- Yair Lapidagainst
- Tatiana Mazarskyagainst
- Shelly Tal Meronagainst
- Yoav Segalovitzagainst
- Yasmin Fridmanagainst
- Matti Sarfatti Harcaviagainst
- Idan Rollagainst
- Elazar Sternagainst
- Naor Shiriagainst
- Michal Shir Segmanagainst
Shasהתאחדות הספרדים שומרי תורה תנועתו של מרן הרב עובדיה יוסף זצ"לcoalition9 for · 0 against — majority for
National Unityהמחנה הממלכתיopposition0 for · 8 against — majority against
- Gadi Eisenkotagainst
- Zeev Elkinagainst
- Michael Mordechai Bitonagainst
- Benjamin Gantzagainst
- Chili Tropperagainst
- Gideon Sa'aragainst
- Orit Farkash Hacohenagainst
- Yifat Shasha Bitonagainst
United Torah Judaismיהדות התורהcoalition7 for · 0 against — majority for
Yisrael Beytenuישראל ביתנוopposition0 for · 6 against — majority against
- Avigdor Libermanagainst
- Yulia Malinovskyagainst
- Sharon Niragainst
- Evgeny Sovaagainst
- Hamad Amaragainst
- Oded Foreragainst
Religious Zionismהציונות הדתית בראשות בצלאל סמוטריץ'coalition5 for · 0 against — majority for
Otzma Yehuditעוצמה יהודית בראשות איתמר בן גבירcoalition5 for · 0 against — majority for
Laborהעבודהopposition0 for · 4 against — majority against
- Naama Lazimiagainst
- Merav Michaeliagainst
- Gilad Karivagainst
- Efrat Rayten Maromagainst
Hadash–Ta'alחד"ש-תע"לopposition0 for · 4 against — majority against
- Ofer Cassifagainst
- Ayman Odehagainst
- Youssef Ataunaagainst
- Aida Touma Slimanagainst
Roll call (91)
Numbers and sources
- For
- 48
- Against
- 43
- Abstained
- 0
- Present, did not vote
- 0
Only members with a record are counted. No record does not mean the member was absent. Official results for votes after July 2021 are not published in the open data.